The FTC’s fake-check guidance identifies overpayment requests as a scam pattern. It explains that a deposit can appear available before a fake check is discovered, and discovery can take weeks. A displayed bank balance therefore does not establish that the incoming check is genuine.
The same guidance warns against using check proceeds to buy gift cards, send cryptocurrency or wire money for the sender. Those instructions matter to a merchant because the outgoing transfer can be difficult to recover while the original deposit is later reversed. Do not describe an outgoing payment as safe merely because the deposit screen no longer shows a hold.
Give the counter a decision boundary
An effective internal rule names the event that needs escalation: an amount above the agreed sale price, an instruction to pay another recipient, or pressure to return money before an independent review. Staff do not need to decide whether a stranger’s story is persuasive. They need to know which manager handles the exception.
Preserve the order, the amount originally agreed, the check details and the sender’s messages in the appropriate restricted record. Keep a clear distinction between a request received and a transfer approved. Otherwise, an employee arriving on the next shift may see a note saying refund and assume that someone has already verified it.
Review the proposed outgoing transaction separately
Use the bank’s independently obtained contact channel when asking about a suspected check problem. Do not rely on a phone number supplied by the person requesting the refund. Explain the incoming transaction and the proposed outgoing payment accurately; a generic question about available funds may fail to describe the risk the business is trying to assess.
This is a fraud-escalation procedure, not permission to retain a legitimate customer’s money indefinitely. If a real payment error has occurred, management should work through an appropriate bank and legal review to determine the correct response. An employee should not invent a new payment route simply to make the complaint disappear.
Owners can review exceptions without turning them into a sales-performance target. Ask whether staff recognized the trigger, preserved the records and avoided making an unauthorized outgoing transfer. Do not reward a quick resolution that bypasses those steps or promise that any checklist makes fraud impossible.
If money has already been sent and fraud is suspected, contact the relevant bank or payment provider promptly and preserve the transaction references. Report suspected fraud through the FTC’s reporting channel. Reporting is not a guarantee that a loss can be recovered.

