Independent coverage for America's merchants
ALL STATE MERCHANTS

INSIGHTS FOR SMBS AND SMES

Small Business

Before Advertising a Holiday Price Cut, Keep the Evidence Behind the Comparison

A crossed-out price needs a genuine basis. Connect the promotional claim to the product, price history and approved wording.

3 min read

A sale tag makes two statements at once: what the customer pays now and why that price represents a reduction. The current checkout price can be correct while the comparison above it is unsupported. Before a holiday campaign goes live, the merchant should review the evidence behind both parts of the message.

The FTC’s guide on former-price comparisons, 16 CFR 233.1, distinguishes a genuine former asking price from an artificially inflated reference used to create a false bargain. It also distinguishes offering an item at a price from claiming it previously sold at that price. The guide does not provide a universal number of days that makes every comparison acceptable; state and local requirements and the actual circumstances also need review.

AMS analysis: identify what the comparison refers to

Start with the exact product and the claim. Is the advertisement comparing this store’s former price, a manufacturer’s suggested price or another reference? Those are different representations and should not be treated as interchangeable labels in a design template. Have a qualified reviewer evaluate the proposed claim and the applicable rules before printing it or publishing it online.

For a hypothetical specialty retailer, match the advertisement to the product variant, quantity and included accessories. A price history for one package does not automatically support a discount claim for another. If the holiday bundle is new, the owner should be able to explain the basis of any comparison without implying a sales history the bundle never had.

Build a record the campaign team can use

Retain the relevant pricing evidence and the approved advertisement together. Record where and when the former offer appeared, what the customer would have received and any conditions affecting the comparison. A spreadsheet entry saying regular price is a conclusion, not the underlying evidence. Keep enough context for a reviewer to understand what was actually offered.

Assign someone to check the final versions across shelf signs, email, product pages and paid advertising. Confirm that a designer has not changed offered at to sold at or enlarged a percentage claim beyond what was approved. If the comparison changes, send it back for review rather than assuming the original approval covers every rewrite.

Connect the offer to checkout and the end date

Test the advertised product through the actual purchase path and verify the current charge, applicable conditions and displayed comparison. Decide who removes or revises promotional material when the campaign ends. Old signs and scheduled messages can leave a claim circulating after the price or product has changed.

When a customer questions the comparison, give staff a route to the person who owns the campaign record. Staff should not invent an explanation based on what a nearby competitor charges. Review recurring questions to identify unclear wording or mismatched product information. The useful discipline is simple: the business can trace the advertised reduction to a specific product, a genuine basis and an approved message, rather than relying on the visual impression of a crossed-out number.

About the author

AMS Editorial Staff

Independent business coverage for SMBs and SMEs, with practical reporting on payments, finance, AI, operations, legal risk, retail and local business trends.

SMBSMEOperationsFinanceTechnology
Related Coverage

Continue reading

Subscribe to AMS

Get AMS articles by email. Confirm your subscription through WordPress.com.

Contribute to AMS

Share your professional experience with retail, online and mobile business owners.

Open contributor application
Add a writing sample, profile or photo (optional)

JPG, PNG or WebP, up to 5 MB.